Does peat free compost work?

Between 2015- 2016 I put peat free compost to the ultimate test, I only used peat free compost for every single plant I grew. Was it a huge mistake?

Peat bogs are irreplaceable natural habitats and a carbon store

Peat compost comes directly dug from rare bogs and marshlands, where the peat is created from dead organic matter over thousands of years. These are rare natural habitats for wildlife that are certainly not sustainable, they are irreplaceable. What garden is worth the destruction of a wild habitat?

The peat also stores huge amounts of carbon, trapping it in the plant matter and stopping it going into the atmosphere where it contributes to global warming. Draining peat bogs allows oxygen in and the carbon that is trapped in the plant matter instantly starts being released. Bogs are very specific habitats that cannot be recreated and once they’re gone, they’re gone.

There has been lots written about peat free compost with the general consensus that “it’s a nice dream but not as good for gardening as peat based composts”. We’ve been washed with news articles, trials declaring peat free the worst of the bunch and lots of other naysaying.

I wanted to test peat free out for myself this year to see what it is really like because I struggle with the value of destroying natural habitat for the sake of a Dahlia in our back yard. I took the plunge and grew all my plants – from seed and growing on – in peat free this year, totalling hundreds of plants.

What I tested

The peat free compost I used:

  • Dalefoot peat free wool compost
  • Dalefoot peat free seed compost
  • New Horizon organic and peat free compost
  • (I’ve since used Sylvagrow too)

The plants I grew:

  • All manner of vegetables for my 125 sq m allotment from legumes, brassicas, alliums, tomatoes, florence fennel, basil, lettuce, chard and much more.
  • Ten varieties of ornamental grasses from seed including Festuca, Pennisetum, Agrostis, Deschampsia and others.
  • Many ornamental annuals and perennials from seed such as Nicotiana, Astrantia, Lupins, Echiums, Fuchsias, Sweetpeas.
  • Dahlia and Canna tubers from last year.
  • Ferns.
  • Many of the above grown on in our garden in small and large pots through summer.

I also did away with chemical fertilisers, instead, for everything I used organic seaweed based fertiliser.

What were the results of using peat free compost?

I was amazed to find that every report on peat free compost I have read to date is at best complete, utter nonsense, and at worst full of lies. For every single plant and seed I grew this year, the results have been leagues better than the peat based composts I’ve used over the years.

Why did I think it was so good?

Raised and grown in pots of peat free compost Raised and grown in pots of peat free compost
  • Structure was perfect for seeds – unlike some other composts where the structure collapses, peat free has a nice open structure that doesn’t become waterlogged or compacted.
  • Every seedling and plant grew better than in any compost I’ve used before – even seeds I’ve had trouble with in the past like Melianthus major.
  • Water retention is very good – interestingly, I find the water retention of peat free better than pure peat based composts. It’s not as good as the John Innes formula type compost, but you can rectify that yourself by mixing in a little good loamy soil and/or sand. However, that said, I find water-logging and compaction a problem with John Innes formula composts and actually much prefer the peat free structure. It doesn’t dry out as fast as other reports claim, instead it provides a safe, good growing level of moisture. As the season progresses, I find it breaks down a tiny bit and improves its moisture retention too in a perfect way. Even in the midst of the current three week summer heat wave it’s been great.


Peat free compost is better than peat based composts.

I want to repeat that over and over again and shout it from the rooftops. Peat free compost is better!

Both the New Horizon and Dalefoot composts were equally as good. Dalefoot has a truly wonderful texture reflected in its slightly higher price. (note: since this test I have also used Sylvagrow which is also very good).

I feel completely misled by some gardeners who swear by peat based composts and some influential publications and TV shows who still promote peat composts as better to their huge audiences. Good on Monty Don bucking the trend on Gardeners World and backing peat free years ago.

For my own extensive gardening needs, peat free has done everything better than composts I’ve used in the past.

IMG_6481 Peat free compost raised peas

Have you tried peat free composts? What are your experiences?

7 thoughts on “Does peat free compost work?

  1. Thanks so much for writing this. I’m new to gardening and knowing use of peat is bad, just assumed the general purpose compost from my local gardening centre would be peat free. Your blog though made me realise peat is still massively prevalent in compost mixes. I can’t see peat mentioned anywhere on the bag, but looking around online I think the Westland compost does include peat.

    So, yeah, thanks for this post – from here on I will be doing my research a bit better and make sure I am getting peat free.

  2. Those are some fine looking plants! Am just about ready to jump into 100% peat-free after testing the water with the padrons this year. The peat impact has started to really bother me.

  3. I’ve been peat-free for years and never have any problems growing ornamentals or vegetables. I’ve not had a chance to try Dalefort, but have been using SylvaGrow this year and it’s the best peat-free I’ve tried. Just wonderful stuff. Doesn’t get compacted or dry out the way peat based composts do, just as like you report Dalefort is like. There really is no excuse anymore to used peat-based composts.

    1. I must try SylvaGrow at some point this year. I think I must be coming to peat free in a golden years of it because everyone reports it being terrible in the past, I have found it to be so much better however. Dalefoot has the nicest texture of compost I’ve come across, it’s wonderful (making it worth its higher price if you can afford it).

  4. I can trace my induction to peat-free back to the days of St. Geoff of Barnsdale who introduced me to coir, probably the original peat-free. I’ve been growing all my summer and winter bedding, and most other stuff, in it ever since. The only downside is that I’ve found it necessary to use a non-organic plant food (coir is totally nutrient-free unless you buy it “pre-processed”). More recently, I’ve been using SylvaGrow when I need something a bit heavier e.g. for filling containers. Had some difficulty sourcing enough this year and so tried New Horizon. Was totally unimpressed with it – large pieces of wood, stones over 10mm and bits of plastic. I use BioChar seed compost for sowing and get excellent results with it. Aside from the warm environmental feeling, I get far better results overall using peat-free than I used to all those years ago when you couldn’t escape peat.

    1. Interesting John – I know others have reported New Horizon to be poor, so it sounds like it is variable across the country. I do find that in pots you have to use non-organic plant food really. I’m less averse to this however if it’s just for flowers and ornamentals as it’s contained within the pot – and because something like Blood, Fish and Bone is starting to appeal to me less. Hopefully one day a company will come up with good slow release organic pellets. I have tried only using seaweed liquid feed but for plants in pots, it just doesn’t seem to do the trick beyond the first 3 – 4 months. The plants run out of steam and start to show it.

  5. I am an archaeologist and will not use peat compost. Started my first ever garden last year after years of living in a flat – a third of an acre that is gradually being brought back from being hugely overgrown. I used coir and new horizon and it all rocketed away, even in the drought. Grew lot of annuals in it but also roses and hydrangeas in containers. I wasn’t particularly careful about mixes, but it all just worked. I can see no excuse for peat, when the alternatives are cheap and work so very well.

Leave a Reply